Review of Meet the Planets
Reviewed by: Marianne Dyson, April 2012
While browsing the Sylvan Dell booth at the annual Texas Library Association meeting, I was immediately captivated by the cover of Meet the Planets, illustrated by Laurie Allen Klein. I picked up a sample copy and was overjoyed to discover the text by John McGranaghan (who wrote Saturn for My Birthday) was as lively and entertaining as the illustrations.
The book uses the creative backdrop of a Favorite Planet Competition. The host of the “show” is Pluto, and the eight planets of the Solar System are the competitors. Each planet is aptly described as part of an “announcement” by the host. For example, Pluto says of Venus, “She’s bright, she’s beautiful, and she’s smoking hot.” He then adds a few pertinent details (temperatures of over 840 degrees Fahrenheit) and concludes with, “As the brightest planet seen from Earth, she’s often mistaken for a star…welcome Venus!”
The illustrations are full of “hidden” pictures and attributes such as Venus’ pose emulating that of the famous statue of the goddess. The major moons of each world are also included in the illustrations. I especially enjoyed the artist’s depiction of Callisto as a black woman and Europa as a girl wearing a scarf with a pin showing a white bull (representing Jupiter). Ferreting out all these rich mythological and historical details (including astronomers and spacecraft) are sure to provide hours of entertainment for curious kids and space enthusiasts alike.
When the reader finishes the story, they can immediately share what they’ve learned by doing a survey of their friends and family to discover which planet should win the favorite planet award. The other activities are more like a test than an exploration (determining place value and answering true/false questions), but should serve to reinforce basic concepts and integrate new information. More activities are available on the publishers’ website.
This book gets a rare (from me!) perfect score on accuracy. Even the proper scale of the planets is provided in the back. The author and illustrator obviously did their homework, but some credit also belongs to Drs. Curt and Susan Niebur who served as consultants. (I had the honor of meeting the Neibers and serving on a panel at a planetary science conference with Susan, who unfortunately succumbed to cancer earlier this year.)
Meet the Planets provides a delightful pageant of the planets for the eyes and the mind. I urge all parents and teachers to use this book to introduce “all eight planets dressed in their Solar System best.” I don’t know which planet you will choose as your favorite, but this book sure is a winner!
This book earns my “exceptional” rating of 6 points for accurate facts, clear descriptions, a highly creative approach to a “common” topic, excellent readability, use of science in the text, and giving perky little Pluto a place of honor as the host!
Title: Meet the Planets
Author/Illustrator: John McGranaghan/Laurie Allen Klein
Ages: 5 and up
Publisher: Sylvan Dell
Retail Price: $16.95/$8.95/$7.99